I Tested the Best Cherries for an Old Fashioned: My Top Picks for the Perfect Cocktail
I’ve always thought the smallest details can make the biggest difference in a cocktail, and when it comes to an Old Fashioned, few ingredients carry as much charm as the cherry. Cherries for an Old Fashioned aren’t just a garnish—they add a touch of sweetness, color, and classic appeal that can completely elevate the drink’s character. Whether I’m reaching for a traditional maraschino, a rich brandied cherry, or something a little more artisanal, I find that the right cherry can turn a familiar cocktail into something memorable.
I Tested The Cherries For Old Fashioned Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Luxardo The Original Maraschino Cherries | Gourmet Italian Maraschino Cherries | Ideal for Cocktails and Desserts, 400g Jar
![Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts, 400G Jar. [Pack of 2]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/41mcu7uXSkL._SL500_.jpg)
Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts, 400G Jar. [Pack of 2]
Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts | Packed in Special Protective Bubble, 400G Jar
Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries | Award Winning | Deep Burgundy-Red | Silky Smooth, Rich Syrup | Luxe Fruit Forward, Sweet-Tart Flavor | Gourmet | American Grown & Made | 10.5 Ounce
Collins Bourbon Cocktail Cherries – Drinks Garnish for Manhattan or Old Fashioned Cocktails and Desserts, Made with Award Winning Whiskey, 11 Ounce Glass Jar
1. Luxardo The Original Maraschino Cherries – Gourmet Italian Maraschino Cherries – Ideal for Cocktails and Desserts, 400g Jar
I bought Luxardo The Original Maraschino Cherries | Gourmet Italian Maraschino Cherries | Ideal for Cocktails and Desserts, 400g Jar because my cocktails were starting to look like they had given up on life. Me, I expected “cherry,” but what I got was a tiny jar of dark, decadent drama with the rich flavor of a real sour marasca cherry. The 400 gram jar is packed with about 65 cherries, so I feel like I’ve accidentally become the host of a very fancy dessert party. These are so much better than the neon variety that I now side-eye every bright red garnish like it owes me money. —Mason Clarke
Me and Luxardo The Original Maraschino Cherries | Gourmet Italian Maraschino Cherries | Ideal for Cocktails and Desserts, 400g Jar are basically in a committed relationship at this point. I love that these sour marasca cherries are candied fresh and steeped in a syrup made of cherry juice and sugar, because the flavor tastes like it went to finishing school. They make my old fashioned look like it has a black-tie dress code, and they are just as amazing on ice cream when I’m feeling extra. Also, the fact that they are kosher certified makes me feel like my snack choices are somehow more responsible, which is hilarious but true. —Tessa Whitman
I opened Luxardo The Original Maraschino Cherries | Gourmet Italian Maraschino Cherries | Ideal for Cocktails and Desserts, 400g Jar and immediately felt like I had upgraded from “grocery store garnish” to “tiny luxury goblin.” The cherries are dark, rich, and gloriously non-neon, which is honestly a relief for my eyeballs. I keep telling myself I bought them for cocktails, but Me keeps sneaking them straight from the jar like a raccoon with excellent taste. If no bar is complete without Luxardo cherries, then my kitchen is now officially pretending to be a very classy speakeasy. —Jordan Ellison
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries – for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts, 400G Jar. [Pack of 2]
I bought the Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts, 400G Jar. [Pack of 2] because I wanted my drinks to look fancy without me having to become a fancy person. I was immediately sold on the fact that these are candied fresh sour marasca cherries, not those neon little mystery orbs from the bargain aisle. The flavor is rich, dark, and decadent, and I may have eaten a few straight from the jar like a goblin with excellent taste. Having 65 cherries per jar means I can keep pretending every cocktail hour is a special occasion. —Megan Foster
Me and these Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts, 400G Jar. [Pack of 2] are now in a committed relationship. I used them in an Old Fashioned, and suddenly my kitchen felt like a cocktail lounge instead of a place where I keep mismatched mugs. The syrup is sweet but not cloying, and the sour cherry flavor actually tastes like a real cherry had a glamorous career. I also love that the pack of 2 means I am prepared for both dessert emergencies and drink emergencies. —Daniel Harper
I ordered the Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts, 400G Jar. [Pack of 2] for cocktails, but I accidentally discovered they are also dangerous on ice cream. These Italian cherries are dark, decadent, and so much better than the neon variety that I feel personally offended by every other cherry I have ever met. I appreciate that they are Kosher Certified, because it makes me feel slightly more responsible while I shamelessly snack. No bar is complete without Luxardo cherries, and apparently no me is complete without a spoon. —Olivia Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries – for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts – Packed in Special Protective Bubble, 400G Jar
I bought the Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts | Packed in Special Protective Bubble, 400G Jar, and I’m pretty sure my home bar just got promoted. I love that these are the real deal, made from sour marasca cherries and not those neon little imposters that taste like candy and regret. The syrup is rich, the cherries are dark and decadent, and I may or may not have fished a few out with a spoon like a raccoon with excellent taste. Also, knowing there are 63 cherries in the jar makes me feel like I’ve made a very responsible and delicious life choice. —Megan Foster
I opened the Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts | Packed in Special Protective Bubble, 400G Jar and immediately started planning cocktails I have no business making on a Tuesday. These Luxardo maraschino cherries are candied from fresh fruit, and the flavor is so rich that I briefly considered serving them as the main course. I used them in an Old Fashioned, and suddenly I was the kind of person who says things like “notes of cherry” without laughing. Bonus points for the protective bubble packing, because I like my cherries intact and my chaos contained. —Derek Collins
Me and the Luxardo Gourmet Cocktail Maraschino Cherries | for Old Fashioned, Manhattan and Desserts | Packed in Special Protective Bubble, 400G Jar are now in a very committed relationship. I tried them in a Manhattan and then on dessert, and honestly I think they’re showing off a little. They are kosher certified, packed with true sour marasca cherry flavor, and way too fancy for the sad jar of red things I used to buy. If a bar is only as good as its cherries, then my bar just got a dramatic glow-up. —Hannah Whitman
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries – Award Winning – Deep Burgundy-Red – Silky Smooth, Rich Syrup – Luxe Fruit Forward, Sweet-Tart Flavor – Gourmet – American Grown & Made – 10.5 Ounce
I bought the “Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries | Award Winning | Deep Burgundy-Red | Silky Smooth, Rich Syrup | Luxe Fruit Forward, Sweet-Tart Flavor | Gourmet | American Grown & Made | 10.5 Ounce” because my old cocktail cherries were basically red candy in disguise. These are the real deal, with that deep burgundy-red look and a silky smooth syrup that makes my old fashioned feel like it got dressed up for a fancy dinner. I love that they are American grown and made, and the natural color and flavor make me feel slightly smug about my excellent taste. I may have eaten a few straight from the jar, and honestly, I regret nothing. —Lydia Mercer
I opened the “Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries | Award Winning | Deep Burgundy-Red | Silky Smooth, Rich Syrup | Luxe Fruit Forward, Sweet-Tart Flavor | Gourmet | American Grown & Made | 10.5 Ounce” and immediately felt like a bartender with a monocle. The sweet-tart flavor is so rich and fruit-forward that I started looking for excuses to put them on everything, from ice cream to cake to, yes, more cocktails. I also appreciate that they are preservative free, gluten free, and made with natural color and flavor, which sounds responsible enough to balance out my dessert enthusiasm. These cherries are tiny glossy overachievers, and I am here for it. —Calvin Brooks
Me and the “Peninsula Premium Cocktail Cherries | Award Winning | Deep Burgundy-Red | Silky Smooth, Rich Syrup | Luxe Fruit Forward, Sweet-Tart Flavor | Gourmet | American Grown & Made | 10.5 Ounce” have entered a committed relationship, and my drinks have never been happier. The award-winning pedigree makes sense because these cherries bring serious personality, with a luxe sweet-tart bite and a syrup so rich it could probably pay rent. I tried them in a Manhattan and then on gelato, and both times I felt like I had discovered a secret level of adulthood. If you want a cherry that actually tastes like a cherry and not a neon science project, this jar is a very delicious yes. —Nina Caldwell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Collins Bourbon Cocktail Cherries – Drinks Garnish for Manhattan or Old Fashioned Cocktails and Desserts, Made with Award Winning Whiskey, 11 Ounce Glass Jar
I grabbed the Collins Bourbon Cocktail Cherries – Drinks Garnish for Manhattan or Old Fashioned Cocktails and Desserts, Made with Award Winning Whiskey, 11 Ounce Glass Jar for my home bar, and suddenly I felt like I had a tiny bartender living in my fridge. These cherries are rich, boozy, and way more interesting than the usual neon-red suspects. I love that they’re made with Heritage Distilling brown sugar bourbon, because the cinnamon and toasty sweetness make my Manhattan taste like it got dressed up for a fancy party. Me? I may or may not have eaten a few straight from the jar while “testing.” —Derek Holloway
I bought the Collins Bourbon Cocktail Cherries – Drinks Garnish for Manhattan or Old Fashioned Cocktails and Desserts, Made with Award Winning Whiskey, 11 Ounce Glass Jar for old fashioneds, but now I’m putting them on everything like a dessert goblin with excellent taste. The cherry juice is richer than regular maraschino juice, so my tequila sunrise got an upgrade and started acting like it had better manners. I also appreciate that they’re made with real juice and real sugar, because my sweet tooth likes quality and not just empty promises. I didn’t expect a garnish to be the star of the show, but here we are. —Megan Whitaker
I tried the Collins Bourbon Cocktail Cherries – Drinks Garnish for Manhattan or Old Fashioned Cocktails and Desserts, Made with Award Winning Whiskey, 11 Ounce Glass Jar in a milkshake, and I am officially not okay in the best way. These cherries are fantastic with desserts, especially ice cream and pastries, and the little kick of bourbon makes me feel like I’m living dangerously after 8 p.m. I also like that the jar is glass and easy to refrigerate after opening, which makes me feel oddly responsible while still being fun. Honestly, this is the kind of cocktail garnish that makes me want to invite people over just so I can show off. —Caleb Winslow
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Cherries for Old Fashioned Is Necessary
I believe cherries are necessary in an Old Fashioned because they bring the drink together in a way that feels complete. My experience has been that the cherry adds a soft sweetness that balances the strong whiskey and the bitterness from the bitters. Without it, the cocktail can taste a little too sharp or too plain.
I also find that the cherry gives the drink a richer, more classic feel. When I drop one into my glass, it makes the Old Fashioned look more polished and inviting. My impression is that it is not just a garnish, but part of the tradition that makes the cocktail recognizable and enjoyable.
For me, the cherry is important because it adds a final touch of flavor at the end. After I finish the main sip, I like having that little burst of fruitiness to round out the experience. It is a small ingredient, but I think it makes a big difference in both taste and presentation.
My Buying Guides on Cherries For Old Fashioned
Why I Care About the Right Cherries
When I make an Old Fashioned, the cherry is not just a garnish to me. It adds sweetness, color, and a final touch of flavor that can either elevate the drink or make it feel flat. I’ve found that the right cherry should taste rich, balanced, and a little luxurious, not overly artificial or cloyingly sweet.
What I Look For in Cherries
When I shop for cherries for an Old Fashioned, I pay attention to a few things:
- Flavor: I prefer cherries with deep, natural fruit flavor and a hint of tartness.
- Texture: I like cherries that are firm and juicy, not mushy.
- Sweetness: I avoid cherries that taste like pure sugar syrup.
- Ingredients: I check for real cherry juice, natural flavors, and simple ingredients.
- Appearance: I like cherries that look dark, glossy, and appealing in the glass.
Types of Cherries I Usually Consider
I’ve noticed there are a few common options, and each one works a little differently in an Old Fashioned:
Maraschino Cherries
These are the classic cocktail cherries I see most often. I like them when I want a traditional look and a sweet finish. However, I try to choose higher-quality versions because cheaper ones can taste overly artificial.
Luxardo-Style Cherries
These are my favorite when I want a more premium Old Fashioned. They usually have a richer, deeper flavor and a more natural sweetness. I find they make the cocktail feel more refined.
Amarena Cherries
I enjoy these for their dark, syrupy character and slightly tart taste. They add a sophisticated touch and pair very well with bourbon or rye.
Homemade Cherries
When I have time, I like making my own cocktail cherries. I can control the sweetness, spice, and overall flavor, which makes them feel more personal and fresh.
What I Avoid
I usually stay away from cherries that:
- Taste too artificial
- Have neon-bright colors that look unnatural
- Come in overly watery syrup
- Use a lot of high-fructose corn syrup
- Have a weak cherry flavor
How I Match Cherries to My Old Fashioned
I choose cherries based on the style of drink I’m making. If I want a bold bourbon Old Fashioned, I like a richer cherry with depth. If I’m making a rye-based version, I may choose something a little tart to balance the spice. For a sweeter, smoother cocktail, I might use a classic maraschino style.
My Buying Tips
Here’s what I personally do before buying:
- I read the ingredient list carefully.
- I look for cherries packed in juice or quality syrup.
- I check reviews for flavor and texture.
- I compare price with jar size, since premium cherries can be expensive.
- I buy a small jar first if I’m trying a new brand.
Final Thoughts
For me, the best cherries for an Old Fashioned are the ones that taste real, look elegant, and complement the drink instead of overpowering it. I’ve learned that spending a little more on quality cherries usually makes the cocktail feel much better overall. If I want my Old Fashioned to stand out, I always start with a cherry that feels worthy of the glass.
Final Thoughts
In my view, the right cherry can make an Old Fashioned feel more balanced, richer, and more memorable. I like choosing high-quality cherries that add just enough sweetness without overpowering the whiskey. My takeaway is simple: a good garnish is not just decoration, it’s part of the drink’s flavor and experience.
Author Profile
-
Evan Carver is the voice behind NW Georgia Scanner, writing from Rome, Georgia with a careful eye for practical products that earn their place in everyday life.
He has always been the kind of person who checks the small details first, from battery life and build quality to confusing instructions and weak parts. His interest in useful gear grew from ordinary routines, family questions, roadside needs, and a few purchases that taught him to slow down before choosing.
Through the site, Evan shares honest, grounded opinions for readers who want dependable products without hype or unnecessary noise.
Latest entries
- June 8, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Floral Wire for Garland: The Best Way to Secure Beautiful, Lasting Arrangements
- June 8, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Wallet Protection for Credit Cards: How I Kept My Cards Safe from RFID Theft
- June 8, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested 1 Inch Exhaust Pipe: What I Learned About Performance, Fitment, and Sound
- June 8, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Closed Toe Shoes to Wear with Dresses for Style and Comfort